Color Blind

I'm never happy with how I've worked color images so I'm always fidgeting with them.  I mentioned in a previous post that if I have a retoucher work on an image I usually don't mess with it (after all, that's why I paid them to do it).  But for some reason when I'm doing the post on an image myself I'm never satisfied.  So, I was playing with this skater image that I like and messing around with the look.  I like them both.  The original treatment of the raw scan is more natural and this version looks a bit more processed.  What do you think (poll below):

[poll id="4"]